Jump to content

Magnetic sump plug


Colin

Recommended Posts

Hi Chaps,

I quite fancy a magnetic sump plug for my 1200 saloon.

Merlin Autosports have loads, but I'd need to know what the plug thread is.

Does anyone have a spec., please?? 

Best, C

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes that is quite a read and unfortunately I think things might be even more complicated as indicated by this article:

NPTF - National Pipe Thread Fuel (Dryseal) Threads (machiningdoctor.com)

Its says our 3/8 x 18 'Dryseal' plugs use an NPTF thread which is derived from NPT but the tolerances are tighter so that an interference fit of the thread root and crest is guaranteed. In plain NPT threads this isnt guaranteed so a seal may not be achieved which could explain why if weve been using only NPT items they so often leak.

The main Triumph part stockists supply magnetic sump plugs but I would guess they are not NPTF and indeed some even come with a copper washer for sealing but of course this depends on the surface surrounding the plug hole which was never originally designed for it....

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's well worth having a magnetic sump plug, especially when running in a new engine. When running in, there is inevitably some ferrous swarf as the new piston rings bed in. Much better to have it caught by the magnetic plug then circulating until the filter captures it.

For an older, well run in engine, the magnetic plug may be less important, though still worthwhile to catch the smaller amounts of ferrous rubbish that may be circulating in the oil.

It's also worth having a magnetic drain plug in the gearbox. If the synchromesh is a little  weak, or a gear change crunches, the dogs on the gears and  collars will produce swarf.

Nigel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Colin.

Apologies for not having spotted that thread. 

Gearbox plug would be good, too. Who hasn't accidentally crunched a gear or two? 

However, I'm not sure I'm clear about which thread is correct (and . . . is the g'box the same?)!

Our original plugs are interference fit, aren't they? So should I be looking at the 3/8 x 18 NPTF, as mentioned?

Nobody seemed terribly definitive about a replacement . . . (or am I just being dim again?!?)

Thanks and Best, C.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, johny said:

As I say, to be sure, all the Triumph suppliers sell part number 155660 as below for our cars. It uses a copper washer to seal which presumably works...

image.png.d5df40e01ec265a8c92390b44b3ffe27.png

 

I have (had) them on my Vitesse on gearbox and sump but they always leaked. Purchased from Canleys 

Paul 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Surely a tight fitting rubber 'O' Ring in conjunction with the copper washer would stop any oil leaks on the Magnetic plug if it's not a Tapered thread?

Gary  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Paul H said:

I have (had) them on my Vitesse on gearbox and sump but they always leaked. Purchased from Canleys 

Paul 

Which is not much of a help, it leaking when cold & not expanded under heated conditions! Choice:- trap swarf but lose oil when cold standing . . . and Gary, surely a rubber 'O' ring would burn off or harden, crack, then break away after not too long (back to oil loss when cold . . .🙂)??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, Colin said:

Which is not much of a help, it leaking when cold & not expanded under heated conditions! Choice:- trap swarf but lose oil when cold standing . . . and Gary, surely a rubber 'O' ring would burn off or harden, crack, then break away after not too long (back to oil loss when cold . . .🙂)??

Colin

If you get the right type of 'O' ring (Nitrile maybe?) it would be ok.

Think about it, there are 'O' Rings sealing the Oil Filters on our cars and they are fine, I don't think it would get that hot anyway.

Gary

  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the base design  of all our plugs is to use a tapered threaded plug none of the faces are machined to accept a washer as a sealer .

its only lasted 50 years .     its a bit late to get paranoid and guys fancy reinventing a simple design that works .

what you may collect on a magnet is pretty insignificant 

if you wish   stick a old magnet to the side of the filter !!

this mag plug  is just a worry update that will leak 

Pete

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you have a magnetic sump plug, you will fund something like this on it.   A horrifying christmas tree of spikey bits!  Gosh that magnet is doing its stuff!

 

Debris in oil... | Ducati Forum

But wash that plug in degreaser, and pinch off the bits between your fingers.  You will find that there aren't any bits - the spikes are an artefact of the magnetic field, and what you have between finger and thumb is the finest powder, like talc.    The finest particle that can be finger-felt is about 50 microns - that small! - and this is finer than that, but still will be caught by the oil filter.

JOhn

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

All good comments - Gary, I did think after I said it that nitrile might work. TBH, the car leaks a bit anyway. At 143k miles, I expect it. I leak at 66 years old! 🤣

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back in the 1960’s my Father worked for GKN making nuts, bolts and various fasteners for Ford and other companies in the motor industry - as part of a contract they were making sump plugs.

After making the sump plug they drilling a hole in the end of the plug and dropped in a circular section bar magnet which was about 10mm long.

The moral of this little story is, go to a model shop, buy a magnet, drill a hole, dob of superglue, drop the magnet in - job done!

Eric

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's a neat solutiion, Eric. Not too far off Pete's remarks! 

DanMi - I was just looking at those. Eric's inexpensive solution is tempting! Did you find you needed a washer of some description?

Best,

C.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

39 minutes ago, Eric Smith said:

drill a hole, dob of superglue, drop the magnet in - job done!

Eric

That's exactly what I did having a number of magnets knocking around.

Danny

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Similar but a tight fit no glue

Previously I had brought a aftermarket mag sump plug with tapered thread it leaked like a sieve so I reverted to an old original supply plug drilled the hole and transferred the magnet 

All hood now

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Eric Smith said:

Back in the 1960’s my Father worked for GKN making nuts, bolts and various fasteners for Ford and other companies in the motor industry - as part of a contract they were making sump plugs.

After making the sump plug they drilling a hole in the end of the plug and dropped in a circular section bar magnet which was about 10mm long.

The moral of this little story is, go to a model shop, buy a magnet, drill a hole, dob of superglue, drop the magnet in - job done!

Eric

The other alternatives are to either stick a large speaker magnet to the outside of the sump - make sure you get one that will grip and not fall off on the first bump - or else tape one to the outside of the oil filter. The amount of debris they'll capture is frightening. Someone used to make a magnetic collar that was fitted round the filter, but easily copied.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, DanMi said:

Were these oil tight? As the article indicates its not just the taper thread you want but one with tolerances that interfere at the tips. Otherwise you can pull it up as tight as you like but theres still a spiral channel all the way around the thread to allow a steady leak of oil....

image.png.329670479f9f4a1d6cd973dce6e6b389.png

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The swarf on a mgne5iv sump.plug can.look horrifying!

 The spikey bits of metal look as if they could do real.damage!

20240613_115057.thumb.jpg.8a4aa3b3a2848774b64c075d4fd558e8.jpg

This is my gear box plug, today.

But their appearance is an artefact of the magnetic field.   Wash the plug in degrease, and pull off the swarf with your fingers.  You will find that it is in fact the finest of powders, like talc.    The particles are microscopic.

20240613_115137.thumb.jpg.2ed904fd8c7ec6649b53dfcdf82c1c3d.jpg

Your fingers are VERY sensitive!  Any particle you can feel is probably only 50 MICRONS across!

John

Edited by JohnD
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...